Why Real Music Demands Silence, Solitude and Headphones.
*On mastery, background noise, and what we forgot about listening.*
**By John Langley | The Almighty Gob**
---
While Britain marinates in enforced Christmas sentiment and every shopping centre pumps out its algorithmically-generated festive playlist for the 47th consecutive hour, I'm sitting in complete darkness with headphones on, analyzing why Brian May's guitar work on Queen's live performance of "A Kind of Magic" represents something this culture has completely abandoned.
The difference between mastery and performance.
It's the same with Christmas itself. There are those—the minority—who observe it as genuine religious practice, rooted in tradition and meaning. And then there's the majority, for whom Christmas has become performative. Something done because it's expected. Background ritual filling the calendar, demanding attention without requiring actual engagement.
Just like the music playing in every shopping centre right now. Supermarkets. Retail parks. Your mate's kitchen while they're "getting in the spirit." It's ambient. Background. Fills the silence that apparently terrifies people so much they'd rather subject themselves to Slade on infinite loop than sit with their own thoughts for thirty seconds.
That's what's happened to music. We've turned actual craft into emotional wallpaper. Something that should demand your complete attention has been degraded into sonic Anaglypta, playing while you do something else that also doesn't have your complete attention.
I choose not to do that.
**What Listening Actually Requires**
If I'm going to listen to something, I need the Three S's: Stillness, Silence, Solitude. Headphones on. Nothing else happening. Complete focus. Because music—real music, the kind that demonstrates mastery—isn't meant to be ambient. It demands immersion or you're not actually listening at all.
I'm not listening for the reasons most people seem to. I'm not accessing memories or "getting in a mood." Some song from 2015 doesn't transport me back to some emotionally significant moment because that's not how my brain files information. I can hear something on the radio and suddenly know every lyric—my brain retains them without effort. Which is bizarre because for someone who works with language as much as I do, you'd expect me to be drawn to how songwriters use words. But I'm not. Lyrics themselves mean nothing to me. Poetic language in songs is just noise occupying the same space as the instrumentation.
What I'm listening for is something else entirely.
**Mastery: What It Actually Looks Like**
I was listening to Brian May's live guitar work on "A Kind of Magic" the other day. The quality of his musicianship was breathtaking. Same with Pink Floyd—I can listen to David Gilmour play guitar for hours. These aren't people playing three-chord wonders. These are musicians who know their instrument inside out.
The guitar isn't a separate tool they're operating—it's another limb. There's a mental connection with the notes being played that's so well-rehearsed, so deeply embedded, that the fingers know where the notes and chords are without even looking. Like a chef with a knife they've used for twenty years—the tool moves before the conscious thought forms.
It's a meditative process. Close your eyes and the notes appear, flowing from intention to sound without conscious intervention. Brian May isn't thinking "fret 7, bend a semitone, vibrato." His fingers are already there because tens of thousands of hours have compressed the connection between intention and execution into pure instinct.
That's mastery. Complete unity between mental concept and physical execution. The difference between someone who can play guitar and someone who's explored every possibility of what that instrument can do.
**What I'm Actually Hearing**
Production quality. The architecture most people never consciously register but can feel when it's done right. Whether harmonies are blended properly—not just technically correct, but genuinely working together as unified sound.
For me, it's like finding the right apple juice. Or any other product. I've tried twenty, thirty different brands. Marks and Spencer Cloudy Apple—that's it. The blend of apples is perfect. Haven't found it anywhere else. Same principle with music. The right elements in the right proportions create something that just works in a way nothing else does.
The EQ decisions. The spatial arrangement in the mix. How different elements sit in relation to each other. All the invisible choices that separate good from extraordinary. That touch of genius takes something from competent to masterful. That's craft. That demands the headphones, the darkness, complete absence of distraction.
**Everything Has Its Place**
It's not just music. It's apple juice. It's food. It's everything, really. And I know how that sounds—like some perfectionist nightmare. But it's not about perfection. It's about quality. Because poor quality reflects back at you. When you're surrounded by things that don't work properly, that aren't constructed right, your mind can't settle.
Everything in life has to serve a purpose. In music, every note, every bend of that note, has to serve a purpose in the overall production. I'm a great believer in keeping everything in its place—there's a place for everything and everything in its place. It annoys me when someone moves something in my home that hasn't been put back where it should be. Things get lost that way.
Same with music. Everything has to be in place, structured, something you can return to and find exactly where you left it. That's what creates absolute quality.
It's a lonely journey, recognizing differences most people never register. But once you notice, you can't pretend you don't.
**What We Lost**
Music is taken for granted now. It's just there. Everywhere. Always playing. And because it's always playing, it's never actually being heard.
I don't have a favorite artist. What I'm looking for is quality. Real quality. Evidence someone didn't just churn something out for the sake of meeting a release schedule. And when I find it—genuine mastery, not competence dressed up as excellence—I'm there with it completely.
But the path to being released nowadays has lost its gatekeeping function. The barrier between ordinary and extraordinary has collapsed. The journeyman musicians—the ones who've put in the decades, who've achieved that meditative state where instrument and intention are unified—they're drowning in the same algorithmic soup as someone who learned four chords last Tuesday.
The ordinary musician can play. The journeyman has transcended playing—they've achieved something that looks effortless because the thousands of hours that went into building that capability are completely invisible in the execution.
Have we lost the ability to tell the difference? When everything is background noise, when music exists to fill silence rather than demand attention, when three-chord competence gets the same shelf space as Brian May's lifetime of mastery—you end up with a culture that can't recognize actual craft when it hears it.
Which is why I'll keep sitting in the dark with my headphones on, analyzing production choices and watching Brian May's fingers find notes most people will never consciously register. Not because I can't listen to music the way everyone else does.
I choose not to.
Because once you've recognized what mastery actually sounds like, once you've trained yourself to hear the architecture beneath the surface, background noise stops being an option. You either give it the attention it deserves, or you turn it off entirely.
There's no middle ground. And there shouldn't be.
---
**SOURCES & EXPERT REFERENCES:**
**Critical Acclaim - Brian May:**
Rolling Stone magazine ranked Brian May #33 in their 2023 list of "250 Greatest Guitarists of All Time" [1], while Total Guitar readers voted him "the greatest rock guitarist of all time" in 2020 [2]. Rolling Stone's editors described May as a "brainy adventurer who's always seeking new effects," noting his achievement in creating "palatial walls of sound" through layered guitar harmonies [3].
Former Van Halen vocalist Sammy Hagar stated: "I think Brian May has one of the great guitar tones on the planet, and I really, really love his guitar work" [4]. Guitar World's analysis noted May's ability to demonstrate "the depth to May's artistry, and how he could take the bare bones of rock 'n' roll and clad it in orchestral [arrangements]" [5].
**Critical Acclaim - David Gilmour:**
Rolling Stone ranked David Gilmour #28 in their 2023 list of "250 Greatest Guitarists of All Time" [1] and #14 in an earlier ranking, citing his "fiery" solos and production mastery [6]. Bob Ezrin, producer of Pink Floyd's "The Wall," stated: "You could give him a ukulele and a Pignose amp and he'd still make it sound majestic" [7].
Guitar World described Gilmour's technique as featuring "soulful blues vocabulary with precise string bending, awareness of space and rests, lyrical vibrato and excellent intonation" [8]. Music educator analysis emphasized that Gilmour ensured "each note he played served the song appropriately," focusing on production quality over technical flash [9].
**Production Quality & Musicianship:**
Custom Boards Finland music analysis described Gilmour as achieving "ethereal beauty...in a league of his own" regarding guitar tone and production architecture [10]. Guitar techniques analysis noted that "at the heart of David Gilmour's playing is some very soulful blues vocabulary" combined with meticulous production choices [11].
**Performance Examples:**
Readers can verify the musicianship quality discussed by accessing:
- Queen's live performance of "A Kind of Magic" (YouTube, streaming platforms)
- Pink Floyd's "Comfortably Numb," "Time," "Shine On You Crazy Diamond" (all major streaming platforms)
**Source Citations:**
[1] Rolling Stone, "The 250 Greatest Guitarists of All Time" (2023)
[2] Guitar World / Total Guitar, "Greatest Rock Guitarist Poll" (July 2020)
[3] Rolling Stone Australia, "Brian May Profile" (October 2023)
[4] Wikipedia - Brian May, citing Sammy Hagar interview
[5] Guitar World, "Brian May's 20 Greatest Guitar Moments" (July 2020)
[6] Guitar Tricks Blog, "Your Guitar Hero David Gilmour" (May 2025)
[7] Ultimate Guitar, "What Makes David Gilmour One of the World's Best" (June 2022)
[8] MusicRadar, "How to Play Guitar Like David Gilmour" (April 2025)
[9] zZounds Music Blog, "Legends of Tone: David Gilmour" (June 2021)
[10] Custom Boards Finland, "David Gilmour - The Story Behind the Best Guitar Sound" (2024)
[11] MusicRadar / Guitar World, "David Gilmour Playing Techniques" (July 2022)